Home
Knee1 Headlines

Unnecessary Knee Arthroscopies Still Being Performed?

Printer Friendly Version     Email this Article     Links/Reprints

Unnecessary Knee Arthroscopies Still Being Performed?

January 15, 2013
Source: The Medical Journal of Australia is a publication of the Australian Medical Association

Arthroscopy is still commonly being performed on people with osteoarthritis (OA) of the knee despite evidence against the effectiveness of the surgical procedure for this condition, according to research published in the October 1 issue of the Medical Journal of Australia. 

Although the number of knee arthroscopies had declined overall, rates had remained steady in those with osteoarthritis in the 9 years to 30 June 2009, according to Dr Megan Bohensky from the Centre of Research Excellence in Patient Safety and coauthors, who studied usage patterns in Victorian hospitals. 

According to the authors, research published 10 years ago and backed by subsequent studies questions the benefit of knee arthroscopy in patients with osteoarthritis. 

"Because arthroscopic procedures can be associated with complications, it is important that they are used only when they are likely to have measurable positive outcomes", the authors wrote. 

"Given the uncertain evidence of effectiveness, general practitioners should encourage patients with OA of the knee who have no evidence of major mechanical derangement to try non-surgical treatments in the first instance", they wrote. 

In an accompanying editorial, Professor Rachelle Buchbinder, director of Monash Department of Clinical Epidemiology, Cabrini Health and Professor Ian Harris from the South Western Sydney Clinical School, University of New South Wales wrote that it was difficult to "shift the convictions of many surgeons". 

They wrote that in contrast to new drugs, promising new surgical interventions continued to be introduced into practice before their proper evaluation. 

"The use of arthroscopy for knee osteoarthritis has been allowed to continue, exposing patients to an intervention that is at best ineffective, and at worst, harmful", they wrote.

Discuss in the Knee1 forums!

Photo: Alex E. Proimos

Previous Stories

Lower Impact Sports Better For Knees

In Children With ACL Injuries, Surgery Delay Can Cause Irreparable Meniscus Tears

Increased Risk Of Post-Surgical Infection After Total Joint Replacement In Patients With High Blood Sugar

more Feature Stories


RSS

KNEE REPLACEMENT SURGERY COST IN INDIA
By lyfboat
more more Blogs RSS

ACL Torn (5th time) questions
By shanvhere

Posted: Apr 18, 2017
I just torn my ACL and medial meniscus, this will be my 5th ACL. I am 38 and was wondering if I can request a knee replavement. I have been told I was to young, but having torn my ACL again should I ...

more more Forums Create a Topic

Total Knee Replacement
Minimally Invasive Total Knee Replacement
Learn about the total knee replacement surgery and rehab proceess from ...
more more Featured Videos

 
Dr. Robert Klapper

Dr. Robert Klapper:

Preventing Knee Surgery
  more
  more Heroes
  nominate a Hero
  Hero policy